The Politics of Intimidation: Higher Education Today

This is a version of a talk I gave to the Greek Coalition of University Teachers (SISPIROSI PANEPISTIMIAKON) in October 2026. A video of the talk can be found in the film/audio section of my website.
I want to speak today about the politics of intimidation within Higher Education. A lot of people who are committed to higher education and critical thinking in all its forms are feeling pretty intimidated! This is a good time to think with the possibilities of resistance.
The ‘crisis of the university’ is hardly new. There have been dire reports for a very long time. The two most influential are probably Bill Readings’ The University in Ruins, published in 1996 – that is, thirty years ago! – and Henry A. Giroux’s The University in Chains, published twenty years ago. Both lamented the extent to which universities were being run like businesses rather than serving a public ‘good’ with the aim of advancing knowledge and critique. They both argued that the triumph of the free market has eroded the university as a space for open enquiry.
We are all aware of current threats:
Dwindling government funding.
Privatizing university provisions.
Concentration of universities within major cities and elite enclaves, resulting in growing inequities by class, gender, minoritized status, and region.
Precarity of academic and support staff: their Uber-fication, if you like.
The introduction of continuous and time-consuming audit cultures.
Short-termism, which is integral to business-led, liberal-managerial approaches, which promotes ‘safe’ research rather than critical, innovative forms.
Like many of you, changes in terminology act as discordant sirens signaling these shifts:
‘Personnel Departments’ have mutated into ‘Departments of Human Resources’ – a shift in emphasis from supporting people to controlling abstract ‘resources’; and many ‘Human Resources’ units are larger than the academic faculties they are managing.
Academic ‘Heads-of-Departments’ have become ‘Managers’ of Schools and, then, have been elbowed out completely by ‘Chief Executives’, usually experienced in business and banking but possessing no university ties, and commanding salaries unimaginable by even the most distinguished professors. Their key business? Not research. Not teaching. Not facilitating either of these things. Chief Executives are focused on budgets.
The education–business panopticon has led to educational values and research being determined by market share, the pet themes of funders, and what they image will tip the university into profit, as opposed to intellectual criteria.
Crucially, this tsunami of anti-intellectualism is as profound in the STEM subjects as in the Arts and Humanities.
This is the case in all countries but perhaps the U.S. experience is worth noting: the majority of Republicans today believe that universities are actually ‘bad for America’, only one-quarter trust scientists, and only one third trust medical science.
The floodgates to increased political interference into the University have opened. In the U.S., the Federal government is exerting direct power over staffing, research, and curriculums. Some universities (Oxford University, in the UK, for example) have invested in hedge funds – opening the door to unregulated financial industries, which use their power to leverage further expansion into university management and student services (such as unregulated, highly profitable student housing).
Universities are making pacts with, if not the devil, then the likes of Koch Industries (the second largest privately held multinational company in the US, with stakes in oil and fossil fuels). Billionaire Charles Koch gives hundreds of millions of dollars worldwide to universities, thinktanks, and academic Institutes, every penny with strings attached, and threats of withdrawing all funds if they question deregulation and free-market fundamentalism. This is only one of many ways private citizens attempt to control university institutions.
For many of us, this has led to demoralization and general confusion. The central parts of our vocation have been undermined: teaching is now about keeping the ‘customer’ happy (which means kowtowing to demands for high grades and educa-ment) (educational entertainment) while research is drowned by administrative and evaluative bureaucracy.
Given high levels of uncertainty, academics have been cowered: it is far easier to simply acquiescence to the demands of neoliberal managerialism than to risk our careers by critique or protest. Homo Academicus has become Homo Zombicus!
In order to think creatively about remedying these crises – not just building a Noah’s ark to ride the waves, but actually ‘drain the swamp’ – it is useful to think about the politics of intimidation.
I am deliberately talking about the ‘politics of intimidation’ rather than ‘the politics of fear’ because I think many of the threats to the university involve subtle forms of power.
Yes, there are immediate, objective threats: being placed on ‘teaching only contracts’, compulsory redundancies, pay cuts, and denials of promotion. But these formidable formal exertions of power (the threats of private universities is one obvious) –are sharpened by the informal mechanisms that create university environments awash with anticipated, subjective premonitions of doom – instilling in academics something closer to anxiety. The knowledge that, if we don’t acquiesce, ‘behave’, or stay quiet, ‘they’ can make things difficult. Intimidation employs mechanisms and processes that make it seem less costly to avoid or not aspire to things. Intimidation seeks to foreclose options in advance of any actual harmful policy. Intimidation tactics cause us to seek pre-emptive actions, hoping (unrealistically) that we will escape the torrent.
Three examples:
1) Attacks on the Arts and Humanities: many of our so-called defenders have adopted arguments that we provide a particular kind of serviceability to business and the economy. Some can even be heard spouting the ideology of efficiency, productivity, and utility. This negative politics leaves us with no room for anything save the paradox of purchasing our intellectual freedom through self-immolation.
2) In all disciplines, we can observe the extent to which university professors have managed their own surrender: conceding institutional autonomy and voluntarily relinquishing academic rule. In my institution, this took the form of the gradual process of non-attendance at the Academic Board. British universities were designed according to Enlightenment principles of a collegiate and self-managed community. One of the biggest shifts caused by the neoliberal ‘new management’ is the weakening of deliberative bodies such as Academic Board, which is made up of the academic staff of the College and student representatives. The Academic Board is important because no final decision on an academic matter may be taken by the governors or Vice Chancellor/Rector until they had sought and considered our opinion. But, one day, our VC decided he did not like the way we voted, so he did a very simple thing: elongated the meetings. An Academic Board that would normally take two hours was extended to four – and most of us simply couldn’t afford the time. We gradually stopped attending, and Academic Board became a ‘rubber-stamping’ assembly of a dozen or so academics who kowtowed to the Leader.
3) Resistance – petitions, marches, sit-ins, and so on – have been vigorously and often violently suppressed. Resistance was cast as nothing more than a hollow gesture – even when effective in achieving its aims. The politics of intimidation is powerful, not because we fail to see the iron fist of power sheathed by the velvet glove; what we failed to see is that the velvet glove sheathed flabby policies.
So it is helpful to remember that Higher Education is a process, not a product. Knowledge is intrinsically as well as instrumentally worthwhile: its mission is transforming its members, students, and communities throughout their lives. Higher Education teaches people to think, judge, and develop a deeper understanding of themselves and the world: contributing to the life of their communities both locally and globally.
In short, Higher Education seeks to transform the world. In an era of fake news, rising authoritarianism, war, and global financial, environmental, and health crises, the need for the kinds of critical thinking that comes from Higher Education are more imperative than ever. This was a fact that the writer H. G. Wells was referring to when he quipped that ‘human history becomes more and more a race between education and catastrophe’.
But, let me be clear: it is important not to catastrophise: politicians and powerful/rich individuals have always attempted to mould universities for their own ends precisely because they understand the importance of controlling how people think.
Of course, effective, progressive change is difficult (my favourite quote is by Harvard Professor Louis Menand in his The Marketplace of Ideas where he writes that ‘trying to reform the contemporary university is like trying to get on the Internet with a typewriter’.
It is important to recognize that the system has weaknesses – and we can capitalize on these faults and clinks in their armour. There are many people here in this room who know how to do this; who know how to ‘make a difference’.
There are two broad forms of resistance: immanent and external.
Immanent forms of resistance involve exposing how, from the powerful elites’ own perspective, they are failing to achieve their objectives. Even according to their own ideas of success, they are losing.
External forms of resistance include building on contradictions between their notion of ‘the good’ and ours.
Of forming coalitions with other professional groups as well as our local communities who share our values, harnessing the political, economic and cultural labour of all progressive groups.
Of exploit our specific proclivities, skills and spheres of influence.
Of embracing a broad diversity of strategies as opposed to attempting a homogenized approach. Of embracing micro-practices of resistance as well as macro-stagings.
All forms of resistance require us to doggedly refuse to give up on our desire – to be the best researchers, teachers, thinkers, communicators to wider communities as well as our students, to be ‘public intellectuals’. This will require us to be bold, tireless in the radical labour we perform, and loud in our claim that universities are our only access to expand consciousness, clarify what kind of world we want to live in, and elaborate ways of being human.



Comments