The 'Return' of the Soldier: Freud and Films during the First World War

If you want to watch a filmed version of this talk, which also includes images and a clip from the documentary, visit the 'Video and Audio' section of my website.
War hurts. Film-makers, artists, and writers addressing the topic of armed conflict face the formidable task of balancing the poetics of revelation against the aesthetics of destruction. This is as true in documentaries as it is for Hollywood epics. Representing the cauldron of combat forces artists and audiences alike to recognise that the body – their body – is no longer a subject ‘good to think’ but an object that is ‘necessary to be’. Moralists repeatedly warn against conflating personal trauma with secondary witnessing, but we need to take seriously the idea that the sights and sounds of the vulnerable and wounded body can destroy worlds beyond the immediate victims.
In this essay, I use the British documentary film – The Battle of the Somme, released in 1916 – to reflect on some of the visceral responses to depictions of extreme violence. My central theme will circle around debates made at the time about the ‘return of the soldier’.
‘Return’ is a central motif of First World War films, burdened as they are with anxieties about the potential aftermaths of a conflict that had caused destruction of unprecedented magnitude. Of course, the figure of the soldier returning ‘home’ has been a central trope in literature from the tales of Ulysses onwards, but creative endeavours emerging out of the 1914-18 war juxtaposed ‘return’ not as a homecoming to domestic stability (á la Penelope), but as something more deeply disruptive: the ‘return’ of the frontline soldier not only concertinaed familiar dichotomies of home front versus battlefront and civilians versus ‘warriors’ but also obscured assumptions about the gulf between human aggression and pacifism. The solder’s ‘return’ brings consciousness of death home.
I will be putting the 1916 film The Battle of the Somme in conversation with Sigmund Freud. The two essays that will concern me are Freud’s ‘Thoughts for the Times on War and Death’ (which he was writing in 1915, shortly before the Battle of the Somme was fought and filmed) and his and Albert Einstein’s ‘Why War?’ (1931). In both, Freud draws on his observations during the First World War to formulate his ideas about human responses to the ‘non-being’ of Others and Self.
For my purposes now, the most important of these essays is ‘Thoughts for the Times on War and Death’, published less than a year before the release of the film The Battle of the Somme. It was, in Freud’s words, his response to a war that was not only ‘more bloody and more destructive than any war of other days’, but also ‘that disregards all the restrictions known as International Law’. Of course, Freud has other questions in these essays, including his compelling reflection that ‘the state has forbidden to the individual the practice of wrong-doing [murder], not because it desires to abolish it, but because it desires to monopolize it’. But, in this essay, I am more interested in his thoughts about how the state’s capacity to turn people into ‘barbarians’ altered their relationship to death. In these two essays, Freud developed his ideas about aggressive instincts (which was a very familiar theme amongst evolutionary biologists in the fin de siècle, and, more originally (and in the 1931 essay), the Death Drive (Thanatos) and Eros.
*
These questions are particularly relevant to the popular 1916 film, The Battle of the Somme. The film is an extraordinary documentary, shot just behind and in the front lines by Geoffrey Malins and John Benjamin McDowell over one month in mid-1916. It shows preparations for and the first day of the Battle of the Somme, 1 July. It is important to note that the film was intended as propaganda but a propaganda film unlike anything before (and, arguably, after).
Released on 21 August 1916, it caused a sensation. It was hailed as the ‘greatest of all pictures’, the ‘greatest moving picture in the world’, and the ‘most wonderful war-film ever shown’. Its popularity was unprecedented. The Battle of the Somme was reviewed in nearly every national, regional, and local newspaper. Crowds of people clamoured for admission outside of cinemas, often being turned away for lack of room. Between fifteen to twenty million people in Britain watched it, that is, between a third to a half of the entire population; some historians claim that practically every adult in the UK saw it. It was the most watched film of the war.
To understand its popularity, it is important to remember that, when it came out, Britons were engulfed in the bloodiest battle they had ever fought, in which the number of people being wounded and killed far surpassed anything preceding it. On the first day of the Battle of the Somme (that is, the day that it was filmed), nearly 20,000 British men were killed, and within the four and a half months of battle, British troops suffered 420,000 casualties. The ‘advance’? Only several kilometres.
Notably: most of the dead were not ‘socialized warriors’ (that is, trained members of the ‘Regular’ forces), nor were they from ‘military families’ (in the pre-1915 British army, nearly half of all personnel had close male relatives also serving in the forces). Rather, they were ‘ordinary civilians’ – volunteers and, increasingly, conscripts: boys barely out of school, labourers, clerks, shopkeepers, and teachers. Civilians were also deeply implicated in the carnage: cities in the UK were being bombed; those living on the east coast could hear artillery fire from across the channel; lists of casualties were being printed, page after terrifying page, in every newspaper in the country. In 1916, everyone was forced to reflect on their own mortality, as well as the death of Others.
These points are crucial if we are to understand the impact of the film. The audiences clamouring to see the documentary were watching it under exceptional circumstances. Everyone in the audience were mourning the injuries, ‘shell shock’, and/or deaths of loved ones, friends, and neighbours; a significant minority of people in the cinemas would have been dressed in black mourning clothes or wearing black armbands; all would have been actively engaged in war work; all would have first-hand knowledge of the relatively new weapons of mass destruction (artillery; bombs, tanks; machine guns); all would have shocked by the number of severely injured and psychologically traumatised men in the streets and hospitals. Since conscription had been introduced in March that year, everyone would have been living in states of dread, if not fear. Newspapers were printing page after page of the names of people killed – there were so many dead, newspaper editors were forced to use small typeface.
Crucially: although the propaganda department making the film intended it to provide people back home with an idea of what ‘the front’ looked like (in other words: nothing like previous, imperial wars; this was the first ‘modern’ war), many of those in the audience were actually hoping to see their sons, brothers, husbands, lovers on the screen. Some did recognize their loved ones. In F. A. J. Taylor’s memoir The Bottom of the Barrel, Taylor mentions how his friend Ted Grainer
sat in the darkened cinema watching this film [when] he became aware that the scenes and the men were familiar to him and he began to recognise some of them and the location of the drama unfolding in front of him on the screen. When with great excitement he saw himself, he jumped to his feet and yelled, ‘That’s me, and that’s my dad, and he’s going to get wounded in a minute’. Then he actually witnessed on the cinema screen his dad getting wounded and being carried away.
The soldiers being filmed understood that their family and neighbours would be watching. Although it is a silent film, soldiers can clearly be seen mouthing ‘Hullo, Mum, it’s me!’, making bows, and waving at the camera. Recognition was facilitated by the fact that, in the film’s intertitles, regiments are named (18 regiments are mentioned). ‘Pals brigades’ (that is, groups of men from the same neighbourhood or city who volunteered together) and the highly regimented (and thus regional) nature of the British army also made identification of ‘locals’ relatively easy.
Others watching the film hoped to see the ghostly reappearance of loved ones who had been reported ‘dead’ or ‘missing’. For such audience-members, watching the film was itself an act of mourning. At the time, most people in the UK died in their own homes (not in hospitals) surrounded by their family and friends: watching the film was, for many, a way of imagining themselves present during their loved one’s last hours. For example: for Frances Stevenson, Prime Minister Lloyd George’s secretary (and, incidentally, lover), whose brother had been killed during the Battle of the Somme, the ‘pictures of men mortally wounded being carried out of communication trenches, with the look of agony on their faces’ enabled her to imagine ‘what Paul’s last hours were: I have often tried to imagine myself what he went through, but now I know: and I shall never forget’. Or, as another claimed, admitting to compulsively returning to watch the film,
I have lost a son in battle, and I have seen the Somme films twice. I am going to see them again. I want to know what was the life, and the life-in-death, that our dear ones endured, and to be with them again in their great adventure.
I want you to imagine, then, responses to scenes that showed British soldiers in less than heroic postures. Of course, as a propaganda film, there were numerous scenes showing men marching into battle singing, waving their helmets, and laughing. But the documentary also shows harrowing images of British as well as German corpses piled on top of each other, burial parties, badly wounded soldiers, dead horses and mascots (a Manchester regiment’s dead dog), and the terrifying impact of bombs and artillery fire. There is also a scene in long-shot where British soldiers are shown marching along the horizon; some fall. These were ‘real’ dead people, ‘real’ corpses. In some of the shots, the troops look exhausted, even dazed. One intertitle tells audiences that it was taken along ‘A sunken road in no-man’s-land occupied by the Lancashire Fusiliers (twenty minutes after this picture was taken these men came under heavy machine gun fire’). Those who are fixing the bayonets in a trench immediately before battle look subdued and anxious.
No scene in the documentary was more discussed than the shot in which British soldiers go ‘over the top’ and audiences literally see them being killed, an unprecedented (then and now) move in a propaganda film. [If you want to see the clip, go to the filmed version of my talk in the Video/Audio section of my website]. Here is how one journalist described the scene:
Then suddenly comes an animation that is amazing beyond words. At the given signal the men go over the parapet. It would indeed be a cold heart that could resist the thrill of battle that rushes upon one from the shivering screen. In the right-hand corner of the picture one of the brown-clad, helmeted men, just as he tops the parapet, instead of going over, slides back flattened out with arms extended against the wall of the trench – the first life sacrificed in that assault…. It seems in a sense horrible to write in this cold-blooded way about one who was once a moving, breathing man.
In another,
The signal is given, and the men go forward with a dash – but not all of them. One seems to miss his foothold and slide down. The spectators watch with breathless anxiety to see him climb to join his comrades. He lies motionless. Then it is realized that ‘somebody’s body’ has passed to the Great Beyond.
The film not only encouraged the celebration of death, as well as repeating the great lie of war: that suffering is redemptive.
The ‘authenticity’ of the film – the fact that it was filmed in the front lines – was crucial to its impact on audiences. [NOTE: in the 1970s, it was found that the section of the film depicting British soldiers 'going over the top' had been faked, but audiences at the time were not awarefact of this]. Up until this time, combat and its aftereffects had been represented in pencil, paint, or, more rarely, photographic plate. As one critic put it in 1916, earlier representations of infamous British conflicts such as the Battle of Waterloo (1815) or the Crimean War (1853-56) ‘were made attractive by bright colours, picturesque grouping of the troops engaged, selection of scenes which had become history’. In contrast, as one commentator put it, in The Battle of the Somme, ‘there are no embellishments from the artist’s pencil, and no effects the result of clever stage management. There is the continuous stream of living men, all in the sombre [sic] khaki’. [Note: the film is black-and-white, so the khaki colour is imagined]. Or, as another reminded his readers, the scene of British soldiers ‘going over the top’ was ‘no arranged piece of play-acting but a record taken in the agony of battle’, a reminder ‘of how far reality… transcends fiction’.
*
It was this element of ‘real’ war – that is, filming real British soldiers being killed – that makes it useful to return to Freud’s 1915 essay ‘Thoughts for the Times on War and Death’. In it, Freud is curious about the psychological mechanisms 1) by which governments persuade ordinary, law-abiding citizens to both kill and risk being killed, and 2) persuade those ‘behind the lines’ to enthusiastically endorse lethal violence against their closest family members and loved ones.
Freud’s chief insight in that essay is that the state, in its pursuit of armed conflict, draws on ‘the deepest essence of human nature’, that is, our ‘instinctual impulses’. These impulses are 1) ‘of an elemental nature’, 2) are ‘similar in all men’, and 3) ‘aim at the satisfaction of certain primal needs’. He argues that the prohibition ‘Thou shalt not kill’ can ‘only be directed against an equally powerful impulse’ since ‘what no human soul desires stands in no need of prohibition’. The formidable weight placed on that commandment is, in itself, evidence ‘that we spring from an endless series of generations of murderers, who had the lust for killing in their blood, as, perhaps, we ourselves have today’.
In normal times (that is, during times of peace), this primal, aggressive instinct is obscured. However, Freud maintained in 1915, this denial of death has a dampening effect: ‘life is impoverished, it loses in interest’. This is why people seek out fictional accounts of dying and death because such representations allow them to experience other people die, and since no-one believes in their own death (as Freud put it, ‘in the unconscious every one of us is convinced of his own immortality’), people enjoy fictive accounts of death because these Others die in place of themselves. In other words, consciousness can only grasp death indirectly, through the annihilation of the Other. As Freud explains,
In the realm of fiction[,] we find the plurality of lives which we need. We die with the hero with whom we have identified ourselves; yet we survive him, and are ready to die again just as safely with another hero.
Representations of the deaths of Others enable people to deny their own (inevitable) annihilation.
This dynamic is dramatically disrupted with the arrival of lethal conflict on the scale of the First World War. Although Freud has things to say about frontline soldiers, in this essay he focusses primarily on civilian confrontations with death during times of mass killing. Why did civilian audiences immerse themselves in filmic representations of death and destruction at a time when they were deeply engaged with the very immediate horrors of actual military conflict, in which hundreds and thousands of people were being slaughtered?
Freud contends that the war
sweep[s] away this conventional treatment of death. Death will no longer be denied; we are forced to believe in it. People really die; and no longer one by one, but many, often tens of thousands, in a single day. And death is no longer a chance event. To be sure, it still seems a matter of chance whether this bullet hits this man or that; but a second bullet may well hit the survivor; and the accumulation of deaths puts an end to the impression of chance. Life has, indeed, become interesting again; it has recovered its full content.
Faced with thousands being killed each day, death was no longer ‘out there’; it was ‘here’ and unavoidable. In the context of which I am writing: cinema audiences were flocking to see the documentary The Battle of the Somme at a time when their own husbands, sons, brothers, friends, and neighbours were being killed in the tens of thousands every day, thus fundamentally confronting them with the ‘reality’ of death – that is, the death of the Other. If we follow Freud’s logic in ‘Thoughts for the Times in War and Death’, state approval of lethal aggression turned wartime-death into a spectacle (a ‘representation’ similar to fictional deaths) that helped shield audiences from consciousness of their own ‘non-being’. In their responses to The Battle of the Somme, audiences were attempting to channel unacceptable confrontations with their own deaths, the deaths of their loved ones, and their aggressive impulses into representations of death.
Of course, as Freud briefly acknowledged (he first wrote about war neuroses in Beyond the Pleasure Principle in 1920, which is where he coins the term the ‘Death Drive’), perceptions of death were different for those fighting in the trenches, rather than merely goading on the aggression of soldiers from the relative safety of theatre cinemas or the homefront more generally. On the battlefield itself, the proximity of death swept away the unconscious’ conviction of its own immortality: primitive desires to kill and not be killed rose into full-consciousness (leading to shell-shock and hysteria). In contrast, for ‘those who have stayed at home and have only to wait for the loss of their dear ones’, both drives remained beneath the surface of conscious awareness. Nevertheless, Freud argued, the large-scale butchery narrowed the difference between the two worlds. As Freud expresses it, war ‘strips us of the later accretions of civilization, and lays bare the primal man in each of us’.
Amongst civilians, outbursts of sadistic imaginings ascended to the surface. I have already mentioned examples of this, particularly in those commentaries about ‘going over the top’ scene. But there are numerous other examples. The Battle of the Somme fetishizes the ‘Spirit of the Bayonet’, or face-to-face/intimate slaying with the bayonet. As officialmilitary reports repeatedly stated, only the bayonet could incite the ‘lust for blood’, a peculiarly Freudian conceptualization in what were non-Freudian times. In the film, intertitles insist that scenes will ‘depict their [soldiers’] effective work with the bayonet’. The breathless prose that appears when reporting on scenes showing soldiers fixing their bayonets and rushing forward into no-man’s-land were clearly intended to give audiences a visceral, bloodthirsty thrill. Commentators report feeling a ‘tingling of the blood and a catch in the throat’ when the film portrayed ‘men leap[ing] over the parapets of the trenches and, with gleaming bayonets, rush[ing] forward’. British soldiers are described as ‘rush[ing] forward amidst a drift of bullets, reeling to earth, panting in the very intensity of feeling, thrusting, stabbing, shooting’, all in a way that ‘‘mingles with our dreams’. In war, another wrote, ‘life is red-hot and lurid, and death stalks naked and grim’, making the film ‘very thrilling and intimate’. Afterwards, the camera was described as lingering over ‘dreadful heaps of jumbled rags lying along a trench floor – all that was left of a German company after our bayonets had gone that way’.
It is important to remind ourselves that, although contemporary war films have led us, today, to think of the First World War as face-to-face slaughter, this emphasis on bayonet-killing is an imaginary one. Even as early as 1916, it was widely recognized by military commanders that modern technologies had limited the usefulness of the bayonet; bayonet charges were seldom ‘pressed home’ (a telling phrase) either because machine-guns, artillery, bombs, tanks, and wire prevented troops from reaching their foe or because the enemy surrendered long before the bayonet stage of the battle plan could be reached. Indeed, without the fantasy of the ‘Spirit of the Bayonet’, anyone watching the ‘over the top’ scene in The Battle of the Somme documentary could only conclude that the bayonet charge was ‘pure murder’.
The Battle of the Somme film evoked multiple sadistic impulses. Audiences in the cinema expressed a strong desire to see the enemy both humiliated and dead. While some members of the audience were said to witness the ‘ghastly tale of what modern warfare really means’ in an ‘impersonal’ manner, other audiences (significantly: they were called ‘spectators’) ‘cheered’ scenes ‘showing masses of German dead on the ground’.
This laying ‘bare the primal man in each of us’, turning strangers into ‘enemies, whose death is to be brought about or desired’, as Freud put it, was most prominent in the parts of the film showing German prisoners of war. Journalists reported that the ‘arrival of nerve-shattered prisoners in our lines’, including one ‘who had both hands uplifted, and was probably saying “Mercy, Kamerad”’, prompted loud ‘laughter’ in some cinemas. When shown German corpses, the popular journalist James Douglas admitted to being unable to ‘forget the race of the dead German soldier who is lying there waiting to be buried by the British soldiers who are digging the graves on the battlefield’. But although ‘these are dreadful sights’, he claimed that ‘their dreadfulness is as wholesome as Tolstoy’s “War and Peace”’. In other words, they fulfilled the function of literature and other forms of representation of allowing sadistic impulses to seep to the surface.
But there is another side to this – and one which Freud understood when he observed that Thanatos and Eros operate in tandem. Audiences exposed to very public ‘British deaths (the ‘over the top’ scene) and piles of British as well as German corpses imagined the deaths of their own loved ones. As one father who had two sons fighting on the Somme, admitted
there is nothing casual… about that part of it [the film] that shows the dead. The soldier who rests as if he had fallen asleep… the huddled heap that was human and is no more….. Dead bodies with upturned faces, and the grave ready. They are German dead, but here the dullest imagination is stirred into activity and thinks of somewhere to which the film does not take us. All our own beloved dead lying thus in the open.If on our side of the line, they are being handled reverently; but if on the German side, they are being placed by stranger hands in rude graves such as we see are destined for our enemies. This is why, in the end, we all leave the building chastened and silent.
This rousing of unconscious desires rendered cinemas sites of intense emotion – or imaginative (dis)embodiment. Although seated in comfortable seats in cinemas 200 miles from scenes of carnage, audiences were unable to stand outside the spectacles of atrocity shown on the screen: ‘you are there, or fancy you are’, one member of the audience noted, ‘until a tilting seat dispels the illusion’.
Cinemas were transfigured as cathedrals to suffering and awe. Attendees reported that there were ‘tears in many people’s eyes’; audiences were in a state of ‘reverence’; people were ‘as quiet as worshippers in a cathedral’; and there was a ‘depth of reverence as profound and pure as ever evoked in the Cathedral’s aisle’. One journalist contended that ‘If to-morrow could be a saint’s day in the secular calendar, it would be dedicated to Thomas Atkins [that is, Tommy Atkins, slang for a Private in the British Army]…. Every picture theatre would be a temple, and every screen in it a shrine’. While women ‘audibly sighed’, ‘strong men found unexpected lumps in their throats, and were thankful for the “dim religious light” of the theatre’. In his typically hyperbolic fashion, James Douglas maintained that watching the film
ennobled and exalted us. There was sobbing in the sacred darkness around me. There was a religious reverence in the silence closing over the sobs. There was humility in our tears.
In this way, the film was s in the creation of an affective community, animated by fear, dread, and a foreboding of dead soldiers who would be coming home.
*
Let’s return to the ‘over the top’ scene in which audiences witnessed ‘real’ British soldiers being killed (only weeks earlier) on the screen in front of them.
Not everyone was convinced that this scene would be ‘regenerative and resurrective’, as Douglas had contended. In the fin de siècle, scientists and psychologists were immersed in pseudo-Darwinian, evolutionary theory, in which frightened individuals very easily transformed themselves into a mob, united by the evocation of one emotion: fear. Important commentary was provided by French psychologist, Gustave Le Bon, whose book Psychologie des foules (1895) or The Crowd (English translation, 1896) was one of the most influential tomes in social psychology at the time and had a major influence on Freud. According to Le Bon (as well as important British thinkers such as Wilfred Trotter and the father of functional psychology, William McDougall), group solidarity led to a return to primitive forms of behaviour, and emotions swung deep and wide through processes of emotional contagion. Trotter argued that, faced with frightening stimuli, people were ‘subjected to the passions of the pack in his mob violence and the passions of the herd in his panics’. Or as McDougall put it, in acute attacks of fear, people lose ‘all human attributes’ and sink ‘to the level of pure animal behaviour’.
These ideas were employed to explain audiences’ responses to visions of death (‘going over the top’ and piles of corpses) in The Battle of the Somme. Numerous commentators asked: were British civilians reverting to their ‘primitive’ instincts? Journalists worried that ‘the fierce animal-passions of humanity’ were ‘triumphing over culture and civilization’. Zoologist E. Ray Lankester, whose writings were (at the time) frequently set alongside those of Freud, was worried that people who had, more than a century earlier, rejected ‘witnessing the hangings at Newgate and the floggings of the mad-men at Bedlam’, were now ‘find[ing] pleasure in experiencing the thrills of horror’ exposed in the documentary. Why, he fretted, were they exulting in images that lingered over the deaths of their own husbands, sons, fathers, and brothers?
Lankester’s lament was precisely what excited Freud’s interest. Why do people persist in believing that showing the horrors of war will encourage peace? Freud wasn’t convinced that it would do any such thing, arguing instead that observing the deaths of Others roused the excitement of being alive. As mentioned earlier, Freud maintained that people ‘seek in the world of fiction, in literature and in the theatre compensation for what has been lost in life. There [in fictive representations] we still find people who know how to die – who, indeed, even manage to kill someone else’. Responses to the documentary The Battle of the Somme suggests that audiences experienced this excitement even when the deaths were ‘real’ ones. They confused ‘real’ death and dying with representations of death and dying. Indeed, the documentary did not deter boys and men from voluntarily enlisting. In fact, spectacles of horror (‘going over the top’ deaths, piles of corpses, and burial parties) as well as displays of romantic heroism (soldiers cheering as they marching into the front lines) fed off each other, creating the sense of enthralment that was inherent to death and dying. Displays of suffering brought value to the warring enterprise. Horror is not antagonistic to the ‘adventure’ (a term used by many commentators at the time) of combat but was an intrinsic component of it.
It was only sixteen years after his 1915 essay ‘Thoughts for the Times in War and Death’ that Freud made a connection between the Death Drive (Thanatos) and the Life Drive (Eros). This happened in the context of an exchange with Albert Einstein, who had been asked to approach a leading intellectual to exchange views on ‘subjects calculated to serve the common interests of the League of Nations and of intellectual life’. Einstein contacted Freud, proposing that they correspond under the title ‘Why War?’
The exchange between Einstein and Freud – published in 1931 – introduced two new elements of relevant to the ‘return of the soldier’ that had not been prominent during commentary about the documentary The Battle of the Somme. The first was that of disillusionment after the soldier returns. In his 1915 essay, ‘Thoughts for the Times on Death and War’, Freud had explicitly rejected the idea of disillusionment. As Freud put it, our mortification and our painful disillusionment on account of the uncivilized behaviour of our fellow-citizens of the world during this war’ was ‘based on an illusion… In reality our fellow-citizens have not sunk so low as we feared, because they had never risen so high as we believed.
In contrast, from the late 1920s, representations of the 1914-18 war homed-in on disillusionment. This shift is best exemplified by historian Samuel Hynes’ characterisation of the 1914–18 myth as ‘innocent young men, their heads full of high abstractions like Honour, Glory, and England’ marching off to war in 1914 and becoming disillusioned. The creators of The Battle of the Somme were part of the propaganda machine that churned out notions of ‘Honour, Glory, and England’ and did not recognize that depicting the slaughter of ‘Englishmen’ might be antithetical to such slogans. By the early 1930s, when Einstein and Freud were writing ‘Why War?’, this position was no longer popular (which is not to say that the heroic myth of war did not continue to be propagated, especially in literatures like Boys’ Own). Artist-messengers, such as Carl Laemmle, the founder of the studio that produced All Quiet on the Western Front, exemplified the myth. Both Einstein and Freud were familiar with the film All Quiet on the Western Front at the time they were writing ‘Why War?’ (In fact, Einstein was honoured with a special screening, and it inspired him to contact Freud). That film rapidly became the model for war films, particularly its themes of progression from the home front to combat, from innocence to experience, and from illusions to disillusions. Henceforth, for war artists keen on representing the ‘authentic’ combat experience, it has become de rigeur to assault the senses of sight and hearing of patrons and audiences by visually and audibly representing the sound of grenades detonating, the stench of high explosives, the metallic taste of blood, and the sight of human bone, muscle, tissue, skin, hair, and fat strewn around.
The second new element is the crumbling belief that the ‘soldier’s return’ (or, more correctly, rising consciousness of the Death Drive) would prompt widespread revulsion against the possibility of future wars. During the First World War, some commentators did believe that seeing the horrors of war visually represented in film might prevent a repetition of mass violence – this is why Prime Minister Lloyd George claimed that ‘If the exhibition of this Picture [The Battle of the Somme] all over the world does not end War, God help civilization!’ and numerous journalists and editorials contended that the film was ‘the finest peace picture the world has ever seen; it is worth a thousand Hague conferences’. Nevertheless, The Battle of the Somme was a propaganda film; its creators believed they were serving British war aims.
By the time Einstein and Freud sat down to write ‘Why War?’, however, it was clear that another war was approaching. The inconceivable was wholly conceivable. In order to prevent ‘the return of the soldier’, both Einstein and Freud called for a strengthening of International Law. In ‘Why War?’, Einstein acknowledged that ‘law and might inevitably go hand in hand’ (an echo of Freud’s comment in 1915) but nevertheless insisted that ‘the quest of international security involves the unconditional surrender by every nation, in certain measure, of its liberty of action, its sovereignty that is to say’. Einstein noted that ‘strong psychological factors’ had ‘paralysed’ efforts for peace, including the ‘craving for power which characterizes the governing classes’. The big question for Einstein was: ‘how is it possible for this small clique to bend the will of the majority, who stand to lose and suffer by a state of war?’ The answer (for Einstein) was that the ‘ruling class… has the schools and press, usually the Church as well, under its thumb’, which enables it to ‘organize and sway the emotions of the masses, and make its tool of them’. He admitted that this answer only provoked another: ‘How is it these devices succeed so well in rousing men to such wild enthusiasm, even to sacrifice their lives?’ The only conclusion was that ‘man has within him a lust for hatred and destruction’, which is latent in ‘normal times’ but emerges in crises.
In the first part of Freud’s response, he agreed with Einstein that the one way to prevent ‘the return of the soldier’ was to institute ‘by common consent… a central control which will have the last word in every conflict of interests’. This would require both the establishment of a ‘supreme court of judicature’ and ‘its investment with adequate executive force’. The League of Nations, a laudable experiment, achieved the first, but not the second, which was why it was inadequate. Law was the continuation of violence by other means.
But Freud went on to address the contention that ‘man has in him an active instinct for hatred and destruction’. Unlike Einstein, however, he added that Thanatos (the Death Drive) existed alongside another: Eros. They operate in tandem: for example, the stimulation of destructive impulses is often infused with idealism and its release facilitated by the erotic instinct. Although there is ‘no likelihood of our being able to suppress humanity’s aggressive tendencies’, Freud argues, however, that
If the propensity for war be due to the death instinct, we have always its counteragent, Eros, to our hand. All that produces ties of sentiment between man and man must serve as war’s antidote.
More tentatively, Freud held out hope in ‘the strengthening of the intellect, which tends to master our instinctive life’ and an ‘introversion of the aggressive impulse’. He proposed that the ‘war impulse’ could be diminished by forming ‘a class of independent thinkers, unamenable to intimidation and fervent in the quest for truth, whose function it would be to guide the masses’. Ideally, every person would ‘subordinat[e] his [sic] instinctive life to the dictates of reason’. He admitted that this was ‘utterly utopian’, quipping that this would ‘conjure up an ugly picture of mills that grind so slowly that, before the flour is ready, men are dead of hunger’. In the end, Freud’s response in ‘Why War?’ was pessimistic: ‘by what ways or byways this [lasting peace] will come about, we cannot guess. Meanwhile we may rest on the assurance that whatever makes for cultural development is working also against war’.
*
In conclusion: This is a good time to think about law, violence, and representations of war. The ‘return’ of the frontline soldier concertinaed familiar dichotomies of home front versus battlefront; civilians versus ‘warriors’; and human aggression versus pacifism. This later was important: as Freud contended, both drives (Death/aggression and Eros/pacifism) were equal and operated in tandem. At the beginning of this essay, I alluded to the formidable difficulties involved in representations of violence, including in documentary film, and suggested that the outpouring of collective emotions and sense of wonderment aroused by watching the film The Battle of the Somme did much more than give audiences ways of reimagining the nation and nationhood (the usual interpretation of the film, and one I agree with). It effectively mobilized affective responses towards 1) ones’ own death as well as 2) inflicting death on others – friends and foe, alike. By dramatically showing the deaths of loved ones and neighbours, it forced audiences to recognise that the body – their body – was no longer a subject ‘good to think’ (as in fictive representations of death that Freud believed enlivened people) but an object that is ‘necessary to be’. It conjured up the mimetic version of psychoanalysis, in which trauma involves a compulsive returning to the site of loss: a repetition compulsion or jouissance. This is the ‘return of the soldier’: not a return ‘home’ but an endless return to violence or, as Freud and (to a lesser extent, Einstein) reflected in ‘Why War?’, a revival of a Death Drive that sends the soldier/civilian back to the frontlines – to kill and be killed. Those waiting for the ‘return of the soldier’ wait for nothing less than the return of primal aggression within themselves.
This is a typescript of a lecture I gave at the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro. The images and clip from teh film can be seen in the Vidio/Audio section of my website. The lecture was part of an international conference 'IX SEMINÁRIO INTERNACIONAL DIREITO E CINEMA “AS GUERRAS DE NOSSO TEMPO”', organised by the incredible scholar Professor Juliana Neuenschwander.



Comments